Talk:Something CAWful

I can't log in Something CAWful. I even tried to create a new account and it said Sorry, you are not permitted to use this board

Since "Something" is no longer a CAW forum
I suggest to remove this from the CAW Wikia directory since it's no longer a CAW Forum.

Just saying since that is no longer the focus. XtremeTony 21:07, October 10, 2010 (UTC)

It's just a name change. Something is still a CAW forum at core, and thus should stay. ~ Amez

So why did they down play CAW?XtremeTony 21:15, October 10, 2010 (UTC)

I agree it's just a name change, nothing else. ~ Eddie

CAW was downplayed a lot of members' interest in CAW is deteriorating. I assure you, it is still a CAW forum. ~ Amez

Well, something like that DOES raise a ref flag, If they're downplaying it, maybe they should just remove the section completely.

It's all in or not at all. Doesn't look good to do it half-hearted.XtremeTony 22:08, October 10, 2010 (UTC)

Most of the members who said CAW is dead runs leagues themselves currently. Obviously caw aint dead and theirs still a CAW forum section on there renamed "shit no one cares for..." and inside it still had a CAW Shows, PPV, Creations, Random Discussioons and, News section. -Danny Jackpot

Whether it's CPV's or Shows itself CAW will not die for a very long time. Not even till 2020 (Well maybe not till 2020 but you get what I mean). ~ Eddie

Who are you to give us advice on how to run our forum, Tony? Clearly we're doing something right, since we already have more than double the members CM managed to get, and it only took us a couple months. Whether or not the forum is "half-hearted", it's still a CAW forum, and therefore the article should stay. ~ Amez

So shooting down CAW is considered doing something right? That doesn't make sense. Just because 1 person doesn't like CAW anymore, shouldn't many everyone else must follow suit.

Also Everyone on CM are about CAW, and making good contributions. I don't know what everyone on "Something" is about anymore. At least the members on CM are there for CAW, and let's not forget that even though I don't go on "Something" too often, I know that most of the CM members are also registered on "Something," and some contribute on both forums, so the number of members that each forum is irrelevant. It's what's presented, and how well the continuity of the members have with one another. That's just the bottom line.XtremeTony 00:42, October 11, 2010 (UTC)

The number of members is relevant; the list of members who visit both SC and CM is far lower than you seem to think. All I can think of at the top of my head are CBCarter, DreConSmith, and Inspector Shetty/King Patch. My point is that obviously we're doing something right since we've managed to rack up more than twice as many members as your forum, and we've only been around for half a year whereas you've been around for like 4 years. Judging from this massive difference in active members, "what's being presented" by SC is a superior forum than CM. Just sayin'. ~ Amez